Okay, lords and ladies, I want to throw my two cents into your hat or ring or shoe or whatever other metaphorical container you prefer I throw metaphorical change in. Just because you’re a published or self-published author does not mean you get to suddenly be an elitist butthole who can dictate what does or does not make a writer, what genres are and are not “real writing”, and what style is or isn’t “art”.
Now I’m not saying that we shouldn’t have standards for things like grammar (except for lovable scamps like Cormac McCarthy) and making things clean and readable for our audience, HOWEVER, what we do not have the license to do, as authors, is tell someone whether or not they’re a real writer.
Example: Yesterday I noticed a tweet from a self-published author that read as follow: “YouKnowYouAreAWriterWhen (it was a hashtag, pardon the unusual caps) you are constantly saying ‘I should write that down’.” My quote-unquote clever response to her was, “YouKnowYouAreAWriterWhen you have a dream that intelligent ducks enslave society, wake up and say, ‘I should write that down’.” Her response to my response was as follows: “Hah. Or maybe not….”
Now maybe I’m just reading too much into this, but that, ladies and gents, sure felt like I just got bitch slapped.
It just so happens that I actually AM working on a short story involving hyper intelligent ducks and class warfare (it’s less funny than it sounds), and it also so happens that I take offense to someone telling me what does or does not make me a writer. So what if I decide to write about ducks? Does that mean I can’t make an intelligent, thought provoking, entertaining piece about duck-human warfare? “Maybe not”, at least according to one author.
Come on, people. We get it, you’re talented and driven and successful, at least in your own eyes. So let others enjoy their own talent, drive and success, even if it isn’t in a medium or presented within a theme that you enjoy or consider “art”. Let me love what I love and I’ll do the same for you.
Who knows? Maybe Urban Duck Fantasy is the next big thing.